ANALYSIS OF OFFICIAL AND ALTERNATIVE ESTIMATES OF INFLATION
Abstract
The mass media frequently accuse official statistics of underestimating the inflation rate (consumer price index – CPI) by half to two-thirds. This paper analyzes potential sources of distortion of the official CPI, concluding that systematic errors causing underestimating are absent, and deliberate distortions are impossible. It also analyzes a number of alternative estimates of inflation and demonstrates that they are based either on the use of a consumer baskets that do not correspond to any real pattern of consumption and deliberately overstate rise in the price level, or on some indirect rationale that does not bear criticism.The only alternative estimate that can be taken seriously is greater than the 2005 official CPI by 2 percent points, that is, by 20 % rather than by a factor of 2 to 3.
About the Author
K. P. Gluschenko
Institute of Economics and Industrial Engineering of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Novosibirsk, Russia
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Doctor of Economics, Institute of Economics and Industrial Engineering of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Novosibirsk, Russia
References
1. Bogdanova T. Indeks okroshki // Argumenty i fakty. 2012. No 27.
2. Bogdanova T. Zhizn’ na minimum // Argumenty i fakty. 2015. No 23.
3. Bessonov V.A. O smeshhenijah v ocenkah rosta rossijskih potrebitel’skih cen // Jekonomicheskij zhurnal Vysshej shkoly jekonomiki. 1998. T. 2. No 1. P. 31–66.
4. Donskih E. Ceny pod kontrolem! // Argumenty i fakty. 2012. No 1–2.
5. Donskih E. Infljacija – 31 % // Argumenty i fakty. 2012. No 52.
6. Donskih E., Korobicyn O. Za 2013 god – opjat’ pljus 30 %! // Argumenty i fakty. 2014. No 1–2.
7. Kuznecova T. Bol’she oficial’noj // Argumenty i fakty. 2015. No 1–2.
8. Metodologicheskie polozhenija po nabljudeniju za potrebitel’skimi cenami na tovary i uslugi i raschjotu indeksov potrebitel’skih cen. M.: Rosstat, 2006.
9. Nikitina V. Kto nam lzhjot // Argumenty i fakty. 2011. No 21.
10. Nikolaev I.A., Kalinin A.M., Tochilkina O.S. Al’ternativnaja infljacija / Analiticheskij doklad. M.: Auditorsko-konsaltingovaja kompanija «FBK», 2006.
11. Nikolaev I.A., Kalinin A.M., Tochilkina O.S. Al’ternativnaja infljacija // Finansovye i buhgalterskie konsul’tacii. 2006. No 3. P. 55–63.
12. Sivkova V. Takie raznye infljacii // Argumenty i fakty. 2006. No 16.
13. Smirnov V. Real’naja infljacija – 40 procentov // Bajkal’skie vesti. 2008, 11 sentjabrja.
14. Federal’nyj zakon ot 06.07.1996 g. No 87-FZ «O porjadke ustanovlenija dolgovoj stoimosti edinicy nominala celevogo dolgovogo objazatel’stva Rossijskoj Federacii» // Sobranie zakonodatel’stva Rossijskoj Federacii. 1996. No 28. St. 3349.
15. Boskin M.J., Dulberger E.R., Gordon R.J., Griliches Z., Jorgenson D.W. Consumera prices, the consumer price index, and the cost of living // Journal of Economic Perspectives. 1998. Vol. 12. N 1. P. 3–26.
16. Gibson J., Stillman S., Le T. CPI bias and real living standards in Russia during the transi-tion // Journal of Development Economics. 2008. Vol. 87. N 1. P. 140–160.
17. Leonhardt D. Seeing inflation only in the prices that go up // New York Times. 2008, May 7.
18. Social’no-politicheskaja situacija v Rossii v avguste 2007 goda. [Jelektronnyj resurs]. URL: www.levada.ru/30-08-2007/sotsialno-politicheskaya-situatsiya-v-rossii-vavguste-2007-goda (data obrashhenija: maj 2015 g.).
19. Hazin M. Real’naja infljacija v RF v 2011 godu sostavit okolo 20 %. [Jelektronnyj resurs]. URL: http://newdaynews.ru/finance/364381.html (data obrashhenija: maj 2015 g.).
Review
For citations:
Gluschenko K.P. ANALYSIS OF OFFICIAL AND ALTERNATIVE ESTIMATES OF INFLATION. Vestnik NSUEM. 2015;(4):41-53. (In Russ.)
Email this article 
