Humanitarian expertise as a method of socio-humanitarian engineering (introduction to the ontology of humanitarian design)
https://doi.org/10.34020/2073-6495-2023-1-030-046
Abstract
The paper presents the conception of humanitarian expertise practice as a method. It is justified that the so-called post-non-classical situation allows coexistence of various ontologies and ontological patterns. It is presumed that these ontologies are project and human-created. The accustomed approaches of learning the world through objects and mastering the world in a necessary way are being replaced with an approach which measures, on the one hand, the constant transformation of the worlds, on the other – the metamorphoses and authors of the projects that go through their own process of changes together with humancreated worlds. The article presents the method of humanitarian expertise understood as the method of socio-humanistic engineering which implies construction and alteration of social worlds and management of metamorphosis of these changes. The author demonstrates that the transition to non-classical situation of self-determination is related to the replacement of the principle of human-sizedness of the world and the principles of objectivity, rationality and cognizability of the world with other patterns: that the world is not objective, not humanscaled, not sensible or rational. It is diverse – depending on the patterns of the designer. The article presents the principle scheme of this method. It describes the situation of launch and initiation of the project aimed not only at creation of new worlds but management of the metamorphosis of the changes in the authors of these changes. It is the unique feature of humanitarian projection and social engineering that differs from previously described experience and practice of the application of the project approach, where the authors of the projects were not the subject of reflexive self-projection.
Keywords
About the Author
S. A. SmirnovRussian Federation
Smirnov Sergey A. – Doctor of Philosophy, Leading Researcher
Novosibirsk
References
1. Maracha V.G., Matjuhin A.A. Jekspertiza kak «institut obshhestvennyh izmenenij» [Expertise as an “institution of social change”], Jetjudy po social’noj inzhenerii. Ot utopii k organizacii [Studies in social engineering. From utopia to organization]. Otv. red. V.M. Rozin. Moscow: URSS, 2002. Pp. 113–132.
2. Petrov M.K. Chelovecheskaja razmernost’ i mir predmetnoj dejatel’nosti [Human Dimension and the World of Objective Activity], Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii [Higher Education in Russia], 2010, no. 4, pp. 108–118.
3. Petrov M.K. Sistemnyj podhod i chelovekorazmernost’ teoreticheskogo myshlenija [System approach and human dimension of theoretical thinking], Sociologija nauki i tehnologij [Sociology of science and technology], 2012, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 97–111.
4. Plesner H. Stupeni organicheskogo i chelovek: Vvedenie v filosofskuju antropologiju [Stages of the organic and man: Introduction to philosophical anthropology]. Per. s nem. A.G. Gadzhikurbanova. Moscow: Rossijskaja politicheskaja jenciklopedija (ROSSPJeN), 2004.
5. Popov S.V. Metodologija organizacii obshhestvennyh izmenenij. Metodologicheski organizovannaja jekspertiza kak sposob iniciacii obshhestvennyh izmenenij [Methodology for organizing social change. Methodologically organized expertise as a way to initiate social changes], Jetjudy po social’noj inzhenerii. Ot utopii k organizacii [Etudes in social engineering. From utopia to organization]. Otv. red. V.M. Rozin. Moscow: URSS, 2002. Pp. 45–78.
6. Rozin V.M. Jevoljucija i vozmozhnosti social’noj inzhenerii. Social’noe proektirovanie (istorija voprosa i problemy) [Evolution and possibilities of social engineering. Social design (history and problems)], Jetjudy po social’noj inzhenerii. Ot utopii k organizacii [Studies in social engineering. From utopia to organization]. Otv. red. V.M. Rozin. Moscow: URSS, 2002. Pp. 5–31.
7. Sinjukova N.A., Smirnov S.A. Mezhdu jetikoj i tehnologiej. Metamorfozy jeticheskoj jekspertizy [Between ethics and technology. Metamorphoses of ethical expertise]. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. Filosofija i konfliktologija [Vestnik of St. Petersburg University. Philosophy and conflictology], 2021, vol. 37, iss. 4, pp. 635–646.
8. Sinjukova N.A., Smirnov S.A. Jeticheskaja i gumanitarnaja jekspertiza: konceptual’noerazlichenie. Metodologicheskij aspekt [Ethical and humanitarian expertise: a conceptual distinction. Methodological aspect], Chelovek.RU [ Chelovek.RU], 2021, no. 16, pp. 26–48.
9. Smirnov S.A. Problema normy v neklassicheskoj racional’nosti [The problem of the norm in non-classical rationality], Filosofija nauki [ Philosophy of Science], 2019, no. 1 (80), pp. 19–57.
10. Tishhenko P.D. Chelovek, konvergentnye tehnologii i otkrytost’ navstrechu budushhemu (voproshanie o smysle cheloveka v cheloveke) [Man, convergent technologies and openness towards the future (questioning about the meaning of man in man)], Rabochie tetradi po biojetike [Workbooks on bioethics]. Moscow: Izd-vo Moskovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta, 2017. Pp. 8–22.
11. Shhedrovickij G.P. Metodologija i filosofija organizacionno-upravlencheskoj dejatel’nosti: osnovnye ponjatija i principy [Methodology and philosophy of organizational and managerial activity: basic concepts and principles]. Kurs lekcij. Iz arhiva G.P. Shhedrovickogo, t. 5. ORU (2); 2-e izd. Moscow: Put’, 2003.
12. Shhedrovickij G.P. Orgupravlencheskoe myshlenie: ideologija, metodologija, tehnologija [Organizational thinking: ideology, methodology, technology]. Kurs lekcij. Iz arhiva G.P. Shhedrovickogo, t. 4. ORU (1); 2-e izd. Moscow: Put’, 2003.
Review
For citations:
Smirnov S.A. Humanitarian expertise as a method of socio-humanitarian engineering (introduction to the ontology of humanitarian design). Vestnik NSUEM. 2023;(1):30-45. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.34020/2073-6495-2023-1-030-046